Caitlin Cary

Caitlin Cary

I’m Staying Out

Yep Roc

The second full-length record from this former Whiskeytown fiddle player may be even better than the first, last year’s excellent While You Weren’t Looking. Cary brings along with her a solid backing band, which includes keyboardist Jen Gunderman (ex-Jayhawks), guitarists Dave Bartholomew and Brian Dennis and drummer Jon Wurster (Superchunk). She also enlists a few friends, like Mary Chapin Carpenter, Mitch Easter, Don Dixon, Thad Cockrell and ex-Black Crowe Audley Freed. The invaluable Chris Stamey again holds down the producer’s chair. Her Whiskeytown bandmate Mike Daly co-wrote many of the songs, but unlike on Looking, Ryan Adams is nowhere in sight.

The record is front-loaded with one great song after another. Cary’s fiddle soars on the powerful, melodic opener “Empty Rooms.” The easy-going “Sleepin’ In On Sunday” shows Cary coming into her own as both a singer and songwriter, while “The Next One” is a dramatic ballad imbued with terrific slide guitar color.

She goes the retro honky tonk piano weeper route for “Please Break My Heart,” a tune co-written with Cockrell. The biggest and best surprise, however, is “Cello Girl,” a fairly noisy rocker with cellist Jane Scarpantoni and an engaging vocal performance by Cary. “Beauty Fades” manages to be both dramatic and homespun. If the title track is a little underwhelming after all that has come before, Cary quickly gets things back on track with the character study “Lorraine Today.”

On While You Weren’t Looking, in a song called “Pony,” Cary sings: “My baby, he’s a pony / He’s the one who loves me only.” Here, “In A While” offers these lines: “You keep his picture close beside you / It’s girlish wishes that never came true / But the pony you wanted when you were a child / Is dead in the ground by now.” The album closes with “I Want to Learn to Waltz,” a gently swaying number with a touch of clarinet.

It’s not a contest, but Cary’s former bandmate Ryan Adams will be hard-pressed to come up with an album with half the depth and personality of I’m Staying Out. This supremely confident disc is easily an early standout for year-end best honors.

Yep Roc Records: • Caitlin Cary:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Recently on Ink 19...

  • Butch Walker
    Butch Walker

    Stay Gold (Dangerbird Records). Review by Andrew Ellis.

  • Belly

    Belly brought lot of grit and a touch of grace to the Bowery Ballroom in NYC.

  • Pickathon 2016
    Pickathon 2016

    Pendarvis Farms transforms for three extraordinary days into the fun and psychedelic fest of your wildest indie music loving dreams, Pickathon. Alexa Harris was there to experience the joys of farm life for the weekend.

  • Money Chicha
    Money Chicha

    Echo En Mexico (Vampisoul). Review by James Mann.

  • Micronotz reissues
    Micronotz reissues

    Mortal Micronotz, Smash, Live, The Beast that Devoured Itself, 40 Fingers (Bar/None). Review by Scott Adams.

  • Big Eyes
    Big Eyes

    Stake My Claim (Don Giovanni Records). Review by Jen Cray.

  • Various Artists
    Various Artists

    Money Maker (Studio One). Review by Bob Pomeroy.

  • Pawns

    A triple bill of underground Goth, led by NYC’s Pawns, transforms Uncle Lou’s into a time machine. Jen Cray did not wear eye makeup, but she did wear a black shirt to the show.

  • Bossacucanova

    The Best of Bossacucanova (Six Degrees Records). Review by James Mann.

  • Ranch Ghost
    Ranch Ghost

    Lookin’ (Rough Beast Records). Review by Jen Cray.

From the Archives