Print Reviews
Chaplin’s War Trilogy

Chaplin’s War Trilogy

by Wes D. Gehring

McFarland & Company

Pop stars come and go, and Charlie Chaplin is now just a footnote in American film history. Born in England and raised on the stage, Chaplin signed with Mack Sennett in 1913 and furiously made movies for about 5 years. In that time he went from comic relief to a star; he wrote, directed, acted and became fabulously wealthy. After 1923 his output slowed down but the results were more complex, more thoughtful, and for the most part, more profitable. Author Gerhing digs deeply into Chaplin’s oeuvre focusing on three landmark films that concern war, or at least an interpretation of war thought Gehring’s eyes. He begins with an analysis of Chaplin’s background, the zeitgeist of pre-war America, and then delves in to the films.

First we consider 1918’s Shoulder Arms. In this film Chaplin sticks close to his trademark character “Charlie”. He’s everyman, does what he is told, make the best of it, grins and bears it. In 46 minutes Chaplin thoroughly explores the absurdities of war. He allows Charlie to make the best of bullets, flooding, and Army drills. This story resonated with both troops in the field and the folks back home. Next we fast forward to 1940; now Germany was expanding viciously through Europe. Chaplin expands artistically with the more complex The Great Dictator; it’s his first sound picture and it draws on elements of Leni Riefenstahl’s Triumph of the Will. This was a risky film parodying Hitler before the extent of his atrocities were known. The risk was not so much from Hitler although Hitler despised the film and had as many copies destroyed as possible. Rather, the risk lay in geopolitics. Chaplin had a high profile and there was still a hope a peace could be negotiated; would he damage the ineffective diplomacy of the day? There was an artistic risk as well; this was not the heart-touching comedy he was known for; but a darker comedy that contrasted his Tramp Charlie as the Jewish barber with the dictator “Adenoid Hynkel”. The movie ends with an open plea for peace; telling people how to think is not funny.

The last film explored is 1947’s Monsieur Verdoux. Here the connection to war is tenuous at best, this 1947 thriller is less about war itself than the brutality of man. Verdoux insinuates himself with older women, kills them and takes their money. Based on a true story, it was not well received, and after it Chaplin’s career and success faded until his death in 1977.

The book is worth reading for its insights in to Chaplin’s style, his approach to film making and the tension between public opinion and film maker’s artistic choice. Both influence each other, and Gehring does excellent work at capture the tension. The book is dense; it reads like a doctoral thesis in film studies with its extensive foot notes, bibliography and need to carefully argue each point to shut out any unexpected academic attacks. While I was familiar with Dictator, I’ve picked up the other two films and plan to explore them in the near future. Chaplin may no longer be on everyone’s lips but he is a significant force in what we expect from film and how we interpret it to this day. If this book can’t make you a film buff, then there is no hope. But here’s a takeaway: no matter how good a film is, war continues.

http://www.mcfarlandpub.com/


Recently on Ink 19...

Fire and Iceland

Fire and Iceland

Interviews

New York filmmaker April Anderson talks with Bob Pomeroy about volcanoes, horses, and making documentaries in Iceland.

Best of Film 2022

Best of Film 2022

Screen Reviews

With a year of festival and microcinema screenings behind them, Lily and Generoso select and review their ten favorite films, six supplemental features, and one exceptional repertory release of 2022.

Laura Citarella

Laura Citarella

Interviews

Director Laura Citarella, of the famed filmmaking collective El Pampero Cine, has created with her newest feature Trenque Lauquen a provocative transformation of her protagonist Laura (Laura Parades), whom Citarella first introduced in her 2011 film Ostende. Lily and Generoso enjoyed an in-depth conversation with Citarella about Trenque Lauquen when it screened at AFI Fest 2022.

New Music Now 009: Sleepyhead

New Music Now 009: Sleepyhead

Features

Join us for a new edition of New Music Now, with our special musical guest, Sleepyhead. All three members of the band are school teachers, so you didn’t hear it from us, but there might be a pop quiz about their album New Alchemy after the show.

Joana Pimenta

Joana Pimenta

Interviews

Back in 2018, Lily and Generoso selected Adirley Queirós’s Once There Was Brasilia as a top ten film. That feature’s cinematographer, Joana Pimenta, has now co-directed with Queirós one of the most expansive political films we’ve seen this year, Dry Ground Burning. Lily and Generoso interviewed Pimenta at AFI Fest earlier this month.

%d bloggers like this: