Garage Sale Vinyl
Garage Sale Vinyl: The Captain & Tennille

Garage Sale Vinyl: The Captain & Tennille

Song of Joy / A&M Records / February 1976

Dismissing the Captain & Tennille based solely on their perceived saccharine-sweet sound and goody-two-shoes image would be to reveal one’s naiveté regarding the duo’s legit roots, authentic artistry, and acknowledged industry cred.

Like most tweenage AM radio junkies of that era, I first heard the Captain & Tennille when their single, “Love Will Keep Us Together” came seemingly out of nowhere and took ownership of the airwaves immediately in the summer of ‘75. Meeting with similar results, the follow-up (re-released) single, “The Way I Want to Touch You” dropped in September. Their sound was catchy and hooky, sweet and sunny. At age 12, I found Daryl Dragon’s mystique to be intriguing and Toni Tennille’s girl-next-door appeal to be rather, um, frustrating.

Even at $4.98 (at Sears), full-length LPs typically were beyond my pre-pube budget. But at just .89¢, I did buy LOTS of 45s — including those first two Captain & Tennille singles. And when their sophomore album, Song of Joy, arrived in early ‘76, I had the good fortune of winning a copy via a call-in radio contest. I’d soon score an additional copy on 8-track, you know, for family station wagon excursions. In short order, Song of Joy became MY “Abbey Road.” Over the years, I’ve also bought it on cassette and CD, as well as another four LP copies from various bargain bins and flea markets, including a vinyl copy I found recently at a neighborhood garage sale.

Crackling with pop / rock crunch, while dripping with soulful, bluesy passion, the self-produced set found Daryl and Toni doing most of the heavy lifting, along with famed studio drummer Hal Blaine and a procession of horn players and backup singers. It ultimately would birth three massive Top Ten singles: “Lonely Night (Angel Face),” “Shop Around,” and “Muskrat Love.”

From the heart-stopping Billy Preston-penned opening title track to the sax / organ-driven “Mind Your Love” to the Gospel-tinged “Smile for Me One More Time” to the irresistible remake of Smokey Robinson’s aforementioned classic, “Shop Around,” to the honey-soaked “Thank You, Baby,” to the funked-up, record-closing “1954 Boogie Blues,” Song of Joy remains a true treasure — as crisp and vital as ever. And it continues to demand respect. Now, if I only still had a functioning 8-track deck. CAH-CLANK!

(5/5) ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐

photo by Christopher Long

Song of Joy Track List


  1. Song of Joy (Preston, Boutte) 3:14

  1. Lonely Night (Angel Face) (Neil Sedaka) 3:16

  1. Mind Your Love (Hubbard) 2:59

  1. Smile for Me One More Time (Tennille) 3:17

  1. Shop Around (Robinson, Gordy) 3:29

  1. Going Bananas (Dragon) 2:10


  1. Butterscotch Castle (Tennille, Dragon) 3:19

  1. Muskrat Love (Ramsey) 3:48

  1. Thank You, Baby (Johnston) 3:38

  1. Wedding Song (There Is Love) (Stookey) 3:18

  1. 1954 Boogie Blues (Tennille, Dragon) 4:54

Toni Tennille

Recently on Ink 19...

The Valiant Ones

The Valiant Ones

Screen Reviews

One of the last of the classic wuxia swordplay films stands as a fitting coda to the grand period of the genre. Phil Bailey reviews a new Blu-ray release of the 1975 film The Valiant Ones.

Best of Five

Best of Five

Screen Reviews

Not everyone can be excited by blocks spinning on a screen, but if you are, Ian Koss recommends you pay attention to Best of Five.



Event Reviews

Jeremy Glazier shoots a CAKE headline show at McGrath Amphitheater.